We make NibQuest, a math and reading app for children, so this research has a point of view. We've kept it to what reviewers wrote, and the method and its limits are below so you can judge it yourself.
What we found
We read 1,691 public app store reviews of 18 popular kids' learning apps, and coded every one of the 727 critical (1 to 3 star) reviews by hand. Three things stood out.
- Most complaints aren't about teaching. Two-thirds of critical reviews were mainly about something that went wrong around the learning: the app didn't load, crashed or lost progress (34%), or the money side broke trust (32%). Teaching and learning design was the main reason in 19%.
- Paywall complaints are growing. 21% of critical reviews since 2024 mention a paywall, up from 18% across all years.
- Happy families want more. When 4 and 5 star reviewers asked for something, the most common request (46% of them) was more content: more levels, older grades, local English and other languages.
What critical reviews were about
Each critical review got one main reason. Grouped together, they rank like this:
| Group | Main reason | Mentioned at all | Main reason since 2024 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reliability and access bugs, logins, lost progress, devices, offline | 34% | 47% | 31% |
| Money and trust surprise charges, failed cancellations, “free” apps that are mostly locked, price, upsells to children | 32% | 42% | 31% |
| Learning design level fit, outgrowing the app, repetition, punishing scores, weak teaching, school fit | 19% | 29% | 22% |
| Parent and family controls, reports, siblings, screen time, privacy | 4% | 8% | 6% |
| Company responsiveness support, updates that removed things | 3% | 19% | 4% |
Broken down into themes, bugs lead by a distance, followed by billing and paywalls:
| Theme | Mentioned | Main reason | Mentioned, since 2024 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bugs: loading, freezes, crashes, audio dropouts | 32% | 21% | 26% |
| Billing: charged after cancelling, trial converted, refunds refused | 19% | 15% | 14% |
| Paywall: a “free” app that is mostly locked, caps, content moved behind pay | 18% | 13% | 21% |
| Price too high, or wants one-time or cheaper pricing | 12% | 4% | 13% |
| Login and account: forced sign-up, logouts, password resets | 11% | 6% | 8% |
| Support: no reply, no fix | 10% | 1% | 8% |
| An update removed something loved | 10% | 2% | 12% |
| Stressful scoring: penalties, timers, tears | 9% | 6% | 12% |
| Teaching quality: quizzes without teaching, wrong marking, poor sequence | 9% | 3% | 11% |
| Navigation: child can't use it alone, accidental taps, clutter | 8% | 2% | 5% |
| Devices: tablets, Chromebooks, rotation, storage | 7% | 3% | 6% |
| Level fit: too easy or hard, placed by age, can't skip | 7% | 3% | 7% |
| Progress lost, or not on the other device | 6% | 2% | 5% |
| Wants more content: levels, older grades, local English, languages | 6% | 1% | 6% |
The ten things parents ask for most
These are the improvements that come up most, each with reviewers' own words. Quotes are verbatim and dated. They describe what reviewers experienced, not a finding about any company.
1. “Just let it load.”
Bugs are the biggest theme overall, and the main reason in about one critical review in five: endless loading screens, audio that cuts out, progress lost when a phone is turned.
“you'll likely find yourself staring at a loading screen of a cartoon fish jumping along the water”
SplashLearn reviewer, Google Play, May 2026
“the test progress is lost just because your phone gets turned up right”
Reading Eggs reviewer, Google Play, April 2026
2. “Charge me what you said, when you said, and let me leave.”
Reviewers of seven of the apps describe trials charged early, cancellations that didn't stick, or the wrong plan charged.
“I cancelled my subscription in 2021, and I am charged every year.”
Adventure Academy reviewer, App Store, December 2025
3. “Show me what's free before I commit.”
Paywall complaints are rising: 21% of critical reviews since 2024 mention one.
“You literally cannot see any content before you sign up for a subscription.”
Epic reviewer, Google Play, 2023
“Annoying that the monthly subscription ($9.99) is hidden until you've installed the app”
Mathseeds reviewer, Google Play, March 2025
4. “Don't sell to my child.”
Reviewers describe membership prompts and offers shown to children.
“There was a gift button jumping in the corner and she assumed it was a daily bonus”
Kiddopia reviewer, App Store, June 2026
5. “Mistakes shouldn't erase progress.”
Scores that drop after a wrong answer are the main reason in 45 reviews of one app alone, with a rise at back-to-school time.
“This app made my kid depressed because the smart score is very unbalanced”
IXL reviewer, Google Play, August 2026
6. “Teach it, then practice it.”
Some parents say an app quizzes skills without teaching them first.
“This is a platform you would instead use to quiz a child on skills they already learned elsewhere.”
Khan Academy Kids reviewer, App Store, 2023
7. “Start my child at what they know, not their age.”
Parents ask for placement by skill, a way to skip ahead, and age settings that actually change the content.
“I even changed the year for 2 year old and none of the games changed.”
Lingokids reviewer, Google Play, July 2026
8. “Don't run out, and don't be babyish.”
Children finish the content quickly, or the app stops at 2nd to 5th grade.
“My 4 year old finished all stories and lessons (up to level 8) in 2 weeks.”
Duolingo ABC reviewer, Google Play, 2023
9. “Speak our English and use our money.”
Families in the UK, Australia and New Zealand ask for local spelling, accents, phonics order and currency.
“children would be considered to be misspelling words like colour”
Duolingo ABC reviewer, Google Play, 2022
10. “Let me, the grown-up, steer.”
Parents want to choose content, lock sections, mute music separately from voices, and have a parent check a child can't guess.
“I wish there was a way for me to control what content is accessible to my kid”
SplashLearn reviewer, App Store, October 2025
Offline play is rarely mentioned, but strongly felt. When one free app removed offline downloads in spring 2026, parents said they'd pay to get them back:
“The app is essentially worthless for us now that they eliminated the ability to download games to play offline.”
PBS KIDS Games reviewer, Google Play, May 2026
What happy families value
A keyword pass over 964 positive reviews is rougher than the hand coding, so treat these as a guide:
- the child enjoys it and asks to play: 58%;
- free, or no ads: 15%;
- used alongside school, a teacher or homeschool: 14%;
- visible progress, like "now she reads": 14%;
- lots of different activities: 9%.
How we did it
- Sample. The reviews each store features on an app's public page ("most helpful" or "most relevant") for 18 apps, in 10 English-language App Store regions (US, UK, Canada, Australia, India, New Zealand, Ireland, South Africa, Singapore, Philippines) and 5 Google Play regions (US, UK, India, Australia, Canada). That gave 1,691 unique reviews: 1,208 from the App Store and 483 from Google Play, dated 2014 to October 2026, 39% of them from 2024 or later.
- Ratings. 456 one-star, 102 two-star, 169 three-star, 209 four-star and 755 five-star reviews.
- Coding. All 727 critical reviews, plus the 192 positive reviews that asked for something, were read and coded by hand against a fixed list of 30 themes. Each got one main reason and every theme that applied. A script checked each batch: every review coded exactly once, only valid codes, and quotes copied exactly.
- Collection. Only pages the stores allow robots to read were fetched, slowly. Reviewer names were never stored.
Limits
- Featured reviews lean towards long, emotional and older reviews, so read the percentages as a ranking, not as precise rates. For a few apps most featured reviews are from 2017 to 2021, which is why the "since 2024" column is the better guide to how things are now.
- English-speaking markets only.
- One person coded each review; we didn't measure agreement between coders.
- Store ratings and prices change. The apps' pages were read on 20 October 2026.
The codebook
The 30 themes, in six groups, with what each one covers: download the codebook (CSV). If you're a journalist or researcher and want the source link for a quote, or to talk about the method, email [email protected].
Where NibQuest stands
Here is how NibQuest measures up on these points, as plainly as we can put it. Some it answers by design: it needs no account, plays offline, never shows prices to children (purchases sit behind a grown-ups check), has no timers or streaks, and runs from Pre-K to 7th grade with one plan for every child on a device. Others, like working well on every budget tablet, are things we're still working on, and reviews will tell us how we're doing.
Cite this
TwoLogPI Apps (2026). What parents complain about in kids' learning apps: 1,691 reviews. nibquest.com/research/kids-learning-app-reviews/