NibQuest

Free resources · Mix-ups

Counting on: why kids count the first number again

For 5 + 3 they say "five, six, seven" and answer 7. They're one short because they counted the 5 as one of the steps. Here's how to show what the steps are.

Counting on is a big step. Instead of counting all eight fingers for 5 + 3, your child holds the 5 in their head and counts three more. It's faster, it leads to mental math, and it has one classic slip.

Why it happens

Before counting on, every count starts at one, and every number your child says is one more object. When they switch to counting on, the old habit comes along: they say "five" as their first step, as if the 5 were one of the three they're adding. "Five, six, seven" is three numbers, so the answer looks like 7.

The same slip turns up when counting back. For 9 − 3 a child says "nine, eight, seven" and lands on 7 instead of 6. NibQuest watches for both, and they usually clear up together.

A worked example

Draw a number line and put a finger on 5. Don't count the 5: you're already standing on it. Now hop three times, counting the hops, not the numbers.

45678910 1 2 3
Stand on 5. Hop once, twice, three times. You land on 8.

Say it out loud together: "Stand on five. Six is one hop, seven is two, eight is three." Three hops, and the answer is 8. Fingers work the same way. Your child says "five" with closed hands, then puts up one finger for each number after it: six, seven, eight. When three fingers are up, stop.

For counting back, stand on 9 for 9 − 3 and hop back three: eight, seven, six.

What to say

"When you count on, start with the NEXT number." And for taking away: "When you count back, start with the number just before." If your child gets 7 for 5 + 3, ask them to show you the hops. They'll usually spot the extra one themselves.

Try at home

When to ask a teacher

Most children count on comfortably by the end of 1st grade. Mention it if your child still counts every object from one for small sums by then, or if counting on and back stays a struggle even with a number line in front of them. Teachers can see whether it's this skill or something earlier, like counting objects one by one.

Where it sits in school

Kindergarteners add and subtract within 10 using objects and drawings (K.OA.A.2). Counting on is named in the 1st grade standards: relate counting to addition and subtraction, for example by counting on 2 to add 2 (1.OA.C.5). By the end of 2nd grade, children know their sums of two one-digit numbers from memory (2.OA.B.2). See the kindergarten, 1st grade, 2nd grade checklists.

Sources