NibQuest

Free resources · Mix-ups

Why is 1/8 smaller than 1/4?

8 is bigger than 4, so 1/8 must be bigger. That's how whole numbers work, and it's the most natural mistake in fractions. Two same-size strips of paper settle it.

Ask which is bigger, 1/8 or 1/4, and a lot of children say 1/8 straight away. They're not being silly. They're using everything they know about numbers.

Why it happens

For years, bigger numbers have meant more: 8 cookies beat 4 cookies. A fraction is the first place where a bigger number on the bottom means less, because it tells you how many pieces the whole was cut into. More pieces of the same whole means each piece is smaller.

There's a second version of the mix-up: thinking a fraction written with bigger numbers is a bigger amount. 2/4 looks bigger than 1/2, but they're exactly the same amount.

A worked example

Cut two strips of paper exactly the same length. Fold one into 4 equal parts and the other into 8. Shade one part of each.

1/4 1/8 same whole, more parts, smaller pieces
Both strips are the same length. One of 4 parts is twice as long as one of 8.

Lay the strips one above the other. The shaded fourth is twice as long as the shaded eighth. Then ask, "Would you rather have a quarter of this pizza or an eighth?" Most children change their answer fast once food is involved.

One thing to say clearly: this only works when the wholes are the same size. An eighth of a huge pizza can be bigger than a quarter of a tiny one. Comparing fractions makes sense when they're fractions of the same thing, and the Common Core 3rd grade standard says exactly that.

What to say

"When the wholes are the same size, more equal parts means each part is smaller." For the second mix-up: "2/4 and 1/2 are the same amount." Fold a strip in half, then in half again, and show that two fourths cover the same length as one half.

Try at home

When to ask a teacher

This mix-up is common through 3rd and 4th grade. Mention it if, by the end of 4th grade, your child still can't say which of two fractions with the same top or bottom number is bigger, even with strips or drawings to help. Fractions build on each other quickly, so it's worth catching early.

Where it sits in school

Splitting shapes into halves, thirds and fourths starts in 2nd grade (2.G.A.3). Comparing fractions with the same top or bottom number, and recognizing that the comparison only works for the same whole, is 3rd grade (3.NF.A.3d). Comparing any two fractions comes in 4th grade (4.NF.A.2). See the 2nd grade, 3rd grade, 4th grade, 5th grade checklists.

Sources