Area and perimeter usually arrive in the same few weeks of 3rd grade, use the same rectangles and the same two numbers. No wonder they blur together.
Why it happens
A rectangle that's 3 by 5 gives your child two numbers and two jobs, and both jobs end in a number. If they haven't pictured what each one measures, they'll grab whichever method comes to mind. NibQuest watches for three slips:
- mixing up the two ideas altogether;
- adding the side lengths when the question asks for area;
- adding only two sides for the perimeter, 3 + 5 = 8, and stopping.
A worked example
Draw a rectangle 5 squares long and 3 squares tall on graph paper.
Area is how many squares cover the inside. Count them, or see 3 rows of 5: 15 squares. That's what you'd need to carpet it.
Perimeter is the distance around. Walk a finger along the edge: 5 along the top, 3 down, 5 back, 3 up. 3 + 5 + 3 + 5 = 16 units. That's how much fence or ribbon you'd need.
Same shape, 15 and 16, and they measure completely different things. One more surprise is worth showing: a 2 by 4 rectangle and a 3 by 3 square both have a perimeter of 12, but their areas are 8 and 9. Same fence, different amounts of grass.
What to say
"Area covers the inside. Perimeter goes around the outside." If your child adds the sides for area, try: "Area counts the squares inside. For a rectangle, that's rows times columns." The "for a rectangle" part matters: rows times columns works for rectangles, while triangles and other shapes need other methods later on. And if they stop at 8 for the perimeter: "Go all the way around: four sides."
Try at home
- Rug and ribbon. Measure a rug or table in hand-spans. How far is it around? How many squares would cover it? Which one would you use to buy a tablecloth, and which for a ribbon trim?
- Twelve toothpicks. Make as many different rectangles as you can with 12 toothpicks. They all have the same perimeter. Which one holds the most inside?
- String around a book. Measure around a book with string, then lay the string against a ruler. Then cover the book with sticky notes and count them.
When to ask a teacher
Expect some mixing up through 3rd and 4th grade. Mention it if, by 5th grade, your child still can't say which one a real question needs (carpet or fence?) even when they can do both calculations. That's a sign the ideas need more hands-on time rather than more formulas.
Where it sits in school
Area as counting unit squares, and as rows times columns for rectangles, is 3rd grade (3.MD.C.6, 3.MD.C.7a), as is perimeter, including rectangles with the same perimeter and different areas (3.MD.D.8). The formulas for rectangles come in 4th grade (4.MD.A.3), and triangles and other shapes in 6th (6.G.A.1). See the 3rd grade, 4th grade, 5th grade, 6th grade checklists.
Sources
- Common Core Mathematics: Grade 3, Measurement and Data (3.MD.C.6, 3.MD.C.7, 3.MD.D.8)
- Common Core Mathematics: Grade 4, Measurement and Data (4.MD.A.3)
- Common Core Mathematics: Grade 6, Geometry (6.G.A.1)
- Mix-up wording and activities: the NibQuest curriculum by TwoLogPI Apps.